It’s All or Nothing, Vale
By: Andrea Beatriz Arango
Genre: Middle Grade, Novel in Verse
Number of Pages: 272
Published: February 11, 2025
Publisher: Random House Books for Young Readers
Dates Read: March 16, 2025 - March 17, 2025
Format: Library Book / Hardcover

After months away from fencing after an accident, Valentina, Vale for short, is finally cleared to go back, but it’s much harder than before. Her body doesn’t move as it once did and some days’ pain is better than others, but what’s worse is the new girl, Myrka. Myrka is everything Vale once was and more. As Vale pushes herself to make up the lost ground, she realizes the injury isn’t the only thing holding her back. If she can’t get over her accident how will she ever move forward?

How do you explain pain to someone

when they can’t see it

when they can’t feel it

when a scale from one to ten feels useless

but metaphors and verbs like

stabbing

hammering

digging

scraping

feel like words I could shout til I run out of steam

but Papi and Mami and Manu

would never actually understand?

As someone who suffers from chronic migraines and who spent nearly five years trying to figure out what was causing them, I felt this passage above. Watching Val learn that her value does not equal what her body can and can’t do was something I needed when I was a lot younger. I started my migraine journey in my early-mid twenties and having to remind myself I wouldn’t always be able to do stuff was hard! I’m excited for younger children to see this story earlier in life so that they can have that already in their mind.

Overall, this is a great novel in verse – both for the younger generations as well as a small reminder for older generations that you may have injuries, or your body may not run like everyone else’s, but having to slow down, take your time with things, or modifying how to you do something is perfectly okay!